Tenkara TalkTenkara Talk
Tenkara Talk
a tenkara fly fishing blog
Search TenkaraTalk
  • Home
  • Tenkara Gear
    • Tenkara Rods
    • Tenkara Lines
    • Flies
    • Line Holders & Spools
    • Fly Boxes
    • Nets
    • Packs, Organization & Storage
    • Clothing & Accessories
    • Wading Gear
  • How-To & Resources
    • What is Tenkara?
    • Tenkara 101
    • Presentation Techniques
    • Streamcraft
    • Tenkara Videos
    • Fly Tying
    • Knots
    • DIY & Hacks
    • Warmwater Tenkara
    • Books & Media
  • News & Fun
    • Trip Reports
    • Interviews
    • Philosophy
    • Humor
    • Art
    • Tenkara News
    • Events
  • Tenkara Links
  • About Me
  • Contact
FacebookTwitterYouTubePinterestInstagram
  • Home
  • Tenkara Gear
    • Tenkara Rods
    • Tenkara Lines
    • Flies
    • Line Holders & Spools
    • Fly Boxes
    • Nets
    • Packs, Organization & Storage
    • Clothing & Accessories
    • Wading Gear
  • How-To & Resources
    • What is Tenkara?
    • Tenkara 101
    • Presentation Techniques
    • Streamcraft
    • Tenkara Videos
    • Fly Tying
    • Knots
    • DIY & Hacks
    • Warmwater Tenkara
    • Books & Media
  • News & Fun
    • Trip Reports
    • Interviews
    • Philosophy
    • Humor
    • Art
    • Tenkara News
    • Events
  • Tenkara Links
  • About Me
  • Contact

Let’s End the Tenkara Civil War!

August 12, 201719 CommentsPhilosophyBy Jason Klass

I’ve had a good talk with several veteran tenkara anglers and here are some of my thoughts on the current state of the tenkaraverse. I think we all really need to stick together and realize that even though the sport has grown, we’re still a niche within a niche, within a niche. We should all be supporting each other rather than fighting each other. After all, this is our reverie–the sport that transport us from the drudgery of everyday life. Why ruin it with ego, slander and hate. Isn’t that what we’re trying to get a break from on the water?

tenkara
About the author

Jason Klass

Jason is an avid fly angler and backpacker. As a former fly fishing guide originally from Western New York, he moved to Colorado and became an early adopter of tenkara which perfectly suited the small, high altitude streams and lakes there. He has not fished a Western-style fly rod for trout since.

Like this article? You might also like these ...
FBSetImage
The Answer to Every Question in Fly Fishing
July 24, 2019
Felt vs. Rubber Wading Boots
Why I’m Pro-Felt
February 9, 2019
Okuma Fly Box
Not all “good” fly fishing gear is expensive and not all expensive fly fishing gear is “good”
August 16, 2016
Tenkara Gear
Hoarders: The Tenkara Edition
June 3, 2016
Daniel Galhardo on Tenkara in 2016
May 15, 2016
Ignoring Local Advice
September 12, 2015
19 Comments
  1. August 12, 2017 at 11:13 pm
    Chris Schatte

    Yes, and a great thought. Would be the best outcome
    But then you have new and exciting “mainstream” products as an outgrowth of the “original” Tenkara fishing in the USA. As an example the Sowbug Roundup has a Tenkara mention on the page. Instead of 1 or 2 choices we have a dozen or more for the same price or more/less.
    Capitalism at its best. Your right since to thrive more the community needs cooperation to expand more. Yes there are the Winston vs Sage vs Orvis vs whatever in the western world but its a rarity to have the vitriol of a vs/vs in the Tenkara world. Well it was a rarity
    Great video!

  2. August 13, 2017 at 5:19 am
    David Noll

    Jason,
    Home run. You nailed it. great video. Thanks for voicing the thoughts of many.

  3. August 13, 2017 at 8:23 am
    Michael Agneta

    Good stuff Jason.

    I actually thought this infighting stuff had cooled down a bit. Hadn’t seen it too much recently (other than in the whole release of the Karasu – man that was a sh*t show), at least at a manufacturer level. Has been awesome to see multi-brand events like the Tenkara Jam (probably the best example), heck even Tenkara USA will have Matt Sment & Yvon Chouinard at the Summit as speakers this year. But then again, I try not to poke behind the scenes too much and while I’m friendly with most, I’m not an “industry insider” by any means.

    I guess this stuff is unavoidable, too many special interests, large egos, “expertise,” and social media platforms in which to amplify the vocal minority.

    I’ve seen through the Tenkara Angler project that the large majority of us just like to fish and don’t care what, where, and how. But there’s always a few that know how to strike a nerve and are excellent at poking the cobra. Suppose the key to combating it is to ignore it. If “we” choose not to respond to those incendiary Facebook posts, etc… they’ll never spiral out of control into 50+ comment runaway trains.

  4. August 13, 2017 at 8:36 am
    Martin Weaver

    Very good video Jason! Life is way too short to worry about what rod you fish, what line you like or what flies or bait you use. My last two outings I fished from my kayak I used my fly rod half the time and my Tenkara rod the other. I caught twice as many fish on my Tenkara rod as that with my fly rod. I enjoy both. I believe all of the gurus in our community support each other in the effort to educate us on methods, techniques and styles of Tenkara fishing. You are right on; enjoy Tenkara while you can and support each other!!

  5. August 13, 2017 at 9:42 am
    David Riley

    Thanks Jason. I am with you all the way.

  6. August 13, 2017 at 1:01 pm
    Dave R

    Jason, I’m glad you addressed this. I think it needs to start with some of the vendors. In May, I attended the Midwest Tenkara Fest. One of the vendors got up and some of the first words out of his mouth was that zoom rods were not necessary. He doesn’t build them, yet there were three others who sold zoom rods. I thought to myself, why even throw that out? But, I did make a mental note that in the future, if I need or want a new rod, it won’t be from him.

    Tenkara is still a new sport in this country and there are some very knowledgeable folks from which to glean information. And from where I sit, there are no experts and certainly, no masters. I doubt if people outside of the tenkaraverse will take notice of the petty in fighting. But those of us within do.

  7. August 13, 2017 at 2:29 pm
    Tom Davis

    Nicely said, Jason.

  8. August 13, 2017 at 5:07 pm
    John Hausig

    I agree 100%. Thanks for sharing, Jason.

  9. August 14, 2017 at 2:04 pm
    Wendy

    Very well said. As an unconventional Tenkara Angler I have acquired a lot of different manufacturers products. I couldn’t tell you one line/fly from another. The rods only by who manufactures them, not which one It is. I love them all! From my 15 dollar rod to whatever. Many are second hand gifted or won, so I have no idea on the cost. I can tell you I love to fish TENKARA.

  10. August 15, 2017 at 6:28 am
    Jeremy Drouin

    The tenkara “civil war” is probably more akin to a domestic dispute, but it’s wasted energy nonetheless. I haven’t noticed much vitriol in the tenkaraverse sites and discussion forums – at least not the ones in my feed. Most of the bickering and conflicting views seem to be between tenkara traditionalists/purists and proponents of the more Americanized version of tenkara/fixed line fishing.

    I chalk it up to growing pains of an emerging fly fishing niche. The more anglers who pick it up, the more who will have differing opinions about the best rods, lines, techniques, etc., and will express those opinions. But you’re right Jason, there’s no reason for the drama, it’s just fishing. 

  11. August 15, 2017 at 12:23 pm
    Jason Klass

    Jeremy, you’re probably right, it’s more like a “domestic dispute”. But I like to use hyperbole. 🙂 I just thought after 8 years, the community would have gotten over the “growing pains”.

  12. August 16, 2017 at 9:21 pm
    David

    Worthy points Jason. The criticism of others over; gear used, technique used, places fished, time devoted to the other different facets of tenkara people pursue, or prices paid for gear is totally unproductive and unbecoming to the people in the tenkaraverse as you call it. The world is full of enough madness at the moment. I can barely stand to watch the news. Whatever tenkara activity brings you enjoyment should be a time of respite from the constant bitching, and the constant pursuit to be unhappy, going on in the rest of the world.

    Enjoy tenkara the way it pleases you the most; whether it’s just fishing alone, time spent learning new fishing strategies from others’ insights, studying tenkara history & culture, or pondering where it’s going in the future. Whatever tenkara activity you find fun should be a place of rest from the stressful things going on in the world. Not more of it.

    If you think low priced gear is low quality – don’t buy it. Let the guy who did be satisfied with his purchase. If you think the quality of gear not worth the high price. Don’t buy it. But also don’t disparage the guy who did find the price worth it. If you think someone’s fishing technique is crap, and not tenkara. Don’t say so. It’s better to just say, Interesting setup and method, but I do it this way – you might want to try it, see if it works better for you, and if you might like it better. And leave it at that.

    From my pov, happiness isn’t found in trying to control others activities or way of thinking. It’s found in working to be more satisfied, and happy with your own activities, level of skill, and ideas. With a pinch of effort suggesting a better way to others, while also not demanding they follow the advice or calling them a fool for rejecting your tenkara-way. [oh, and fwiw, I purchased a Karasu400 rod, trusting the development team knew what would be a quality rod, and reasoning that in the end the price will be inline with the prices for a Shimano 44NP, Daiwa Expert L 45m, Tenryu TF39, etc. after the discounts on future DT products are deducted from the initial price. Now and again you have to take a risk to access if your thinking processes are still sound. Sometimes it is, but sometimes not and you pay for a lesson to correct it. And do better next time. Only the dead don’t try something new. They also don’t argue with or criticizes others. The living can make a choice not to also.]

  13. August 17, 2017 at 9:20 am
    Gressak

    Jason,

    Great Note and reminder. I can only expect that this journey of tenkara as sport will only get more and more complicated. I see this as a normal progression. It stinks to have something that seemed so impervious to complication….become fragmented and complicated. I am not sure if there is a fix for this.

    In terms of internal conflict of the community. Some people always find the need for conflict, and conflict seems to be the name of the times. Some of this is spill over from other aspects of life.

    Aspects of Fishing are personal religion and not everyone is going to agree…and some feel a need to fight about it.

    The few (non-tenkara) social media groups I am a member in are all tainted with similar conflicts and disagreements. Somehow social media harbors bad behavior. It probably would be a wonderful sociology thesis. The conflict going on with tenkara is not isolated, and probably not curable.

    I dig your site. Thank you for providing it to us. Your site and a few other are harbors from the BS…..keep up the good work.

  14. August 23, 2017 at 1:56 pm
    Cliff

    I guess I’ve been too busy fishing to really pay attention to all this conflict!

    Life is too short and time is too precious to waste our energy on worrying about what others think about how you choose to tenkara. What matters is how you choose to enjoy it on your own terms, and how you share your passion with others.

  15. August 26, 2017 at 7:29 pm
    IAN

    Good on you for posting this. Returning to fly fishing after a 15 year dry spell and I have a new perspective on fishing. 15 years ago the interwebs were nothing like they are today. Back then I was gathering info from the fly shop and other seasoned fly anglers. Not to say that the info was wrong but I always felt like I had to do the right thing. This time around I have been sucking up my info on line in a somewhat alacarte method. Find something from one style / method, add it to another, see if it works, see if its fun…. All without fear of upsetting the gurus. After all, most of us are doing this for fun.

    For the sport to grow it needs to not have roadblocks.
    Rock on!

  16. September 1, 2017 at 7:49 pm
    Chuck

    Bravo! Concur completely….Its just fishing….to use a phrase lets all “coexist”

  17. November 7, 2017 at 8:23 am
    Sam lucido

    I am considering trying tenkara. Is tenkara appropriate for slightly larger streams like 40 or 50′ wide and targeting trout up to 20″?

  18. March 23, 2018 at 2:33 pm
    Tom

    Wow! I guess I hadn’t even realized there was some in fighting going on. But you did a good job and I agree.

  19. August 3, 2018 at 3:02 am
    Rob Funderburk

    My first bike cost $99 and I love it still. My last bike cost $5000 and it is worth every penney. My first Tenkara kit cost me $120 and I fell in love with the sport. My last rod cost $550 and is worth every penny. My first bike is long gone and I don’t fish my first Tenkara rod anymore. But I do lend it to my friends. I am grateful to be able to share Tenkara with my fishing buddies. Last weekend I outfished my buddy who also happened to be a fish wrangler for the movie “A River Runs Through It” . He was fishing traditional western fly fishing, I was using Tenkara. We both had a blast and I am lending him my Iwana for the rest of the summer. I’ll fish my Tenryu, Daiwa and Nissin. (Yeah, I admit it , I am hooked).
    I am grateful that I have the resources to evolve my Tenkara and biking obsessions but If I couldn’t, I would still bike and fish. I would call this Tenkara fuss a classic first world problem.

Leave Comment

Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

clear formSubmit

About Me

Jason Klass is a former fly fishing guide & casting instructor based in Colorado. He was an early adopter of tenkara in the West and has been fishing the method for a variety of species since 2009. Read more >>

TenkaraTalk Sponsors
Tenkara USA   Dragontail Tenkara     TAO Tenkara   Tenkara Tanuki Tenkara Fisher
Search by Category
Send Jason an Email
Search TenkaraTalk
Tenkara Talk Archives
Tenkara + Backpacking!
Is there any other sport that goes better with tenkara than hiking and backpacking? Be sure to also check out my ultralight and DIY backpacking gear blog.

Tenkara and Backpacking
Latest Posts
  • Tenkara Book
    Tenkara Today Book Review
    November 7, 2020
  • Tenkara Tanuki Retractor
    Tenkara Tanuki Retractor
    October 28, 2020
  • Hoo Rag
    The Hoo Rag
    September 23, 2020
© 2019 | TenkaraTalk by Jason Klass | All rights reserved